Monday, December 1, 2014

LotF Chapter 10: The Shell and the Glasses

 The boys have many different ways of coping with the murder of Simon on the beach. First, Ralph feels extremely guilty about what happened and when he talks about it with Piggy he says, " 'That was murder... 'I wasn't scared,' said Ralph slowly, 'I was- I don't know what I was' " (Golding 224). This shows how shocked Ralph is by the fact that the boys killed Simon, and how he is still so connected to the morals and reality of civilization despite the circumstances on the island. Piggy is also bothered by the way that the boys killed Simon, but instead of letting fear and feelings consume him he takes a more logical and rational approach to coping with the situation. For instance, when he is talking to Ralph about Simon he says, " 'It was dark. There was that- that bloody dance. There was lighting and thunder and rain. We was scared' " (Golding 224). Piggy is also ashamed and scared that the boys could do something so evil to Simon, but he tries to make sense of the situation by taking the facts of the situation into consideration to justify letting Simon get killed by the other boys for himself. Lastly, the savage hunters and Jack are not even bothered by what they did to Simon. They are so consumed by the life that they have created on the island that they have lost all of their morals and values and do not feel sorry or sad or scared after killing Simon. They display this when Stanley says, " 'I expect the beast disguised itself' " and they all agree that the beast disguised itself as Simon to attack them (Golding 231). This exemplifies how the hunters have lost their sense of reality because they are so caught up in fighting the beast that they would even kill one of their own if they thought he was a disguise for the beast. Even their belief in the beast shows how the savage boys have completely lost the sense of reality that was once present in their lives. This changes things on the island because instead of being mad at the hunters for acting like savages, Ralph and Piggy actually start to become afraid of them because they now realize that the savages have lost their morals and are not afraid to kill them if they feel threatened. Given their ages and the situation at hand, I do think that their reactions to the murder of Simon are realistic because Ralph and Piggy both show how the rational and civilized part of a society reacts to tragedy by acting scared and trying to sort it out for themselves, while the savage hunters led by Jack show how mob mentality can make each member of a group feel like it is not their responsibility when they do something bad and therefore take the guilt off of their shoulders. The two groups of boys have very different reactions to Simon's death due to their different senses of reality and whether or not they have held on to their morals and consciences as time goes by on the island.  

No comments:

Post a Comment